As an avid reader of Agatha Christie,
I just had to pick up one of her most famous novels The Mysterious Affair at Styles. Then later on, my boyfriend got me
Curtain: Poirot’s Last Case – a book
I have deliberately skipped as I wanted to postpone reading *his* last book for as long as I could.
However, sooner or later I had to face it, and I preferred to know how it all
ends, anyway.
I thought it would be best to write a
post dedicated to both of those books as they make up a whole circle, starting
with Christie’s first novel starring the little Belgian detective, and going
all the way to his last case.
“Everything must be taken into account. If the fact will not fit the
theory---let the theory go.”
The Mysterious Affair at Styles is a masterpiece – great writing combined with a superb
twist, this is Agatha still at her beginning. In her very first novel, Agatha Christie
introduces some of her most infamous characters: Hercule Poirot, Hastings and
Inspector Japp. A dynamic trio that will go on to solve a lot more mysteries
together (Poirot will do most of the solving of course, and Hastings will do
most of the confusion). Here, Agatha Christie also presents another element
that often occurs in her stories – strychnine
poisoning.
As for the Affair
at Styles in particular, the mystery is around Emily Inglethorp’s murder. Everyone’s
main suspect is her younger husband, Alfred, but of course her household is
full of people, so naturally deep down everyone could be suspicious of
everyone. There are her two stepsons, John and Lawrence Cavendish, John’s wife
Mary, young Cynthia Murdoch, and Emily’s companion Evelyn Howard. At the time
of the murder, Hastings also stays in the Styles manor as a guest to his old
friend John, while Hercule Poirot enters the scene as Belgian refugee (the book
is set during World War I).
The story grabs you from the very
first page as usually with a Christie novel – the clues keep coming and Hastings
keeps getting excited after each one of them. Of course, Poirot is always a
step ahead everyone else. Keep reading, the murderer might surprise you.
“Everyone is a potential murderer-in everyone there arises from time to
time the wish to kill-though not the will to kill.”
In my opinion, Curtain is even better. By this time, Christie is already a very
well-known author, her writing is more confident and her style has turned into an
epitome of her name. A signature murder mystery, this one raises a lot of
questions about the mind of a murderer, grips the reader, and makes him
question everything he has read so far. Every chapter brings new possibilities,
for every person, indeed, could be a
murderer.
In his last ever case, Hercule Poirot
is back at Styles. So is Hastings. And to both of them the house is full of
memories – not just memories of a murder, but memories of their younger years
and with that of their younger selves. If there is one strong feeling about this
book it is that of nostalgia, and nothing strikes the reader quite as hard as
Hastings’ very last description of his old friend that starts like this: “Nothing is so sad, in my opinion, as the
devastation wrought by age. My poor friend. I have described him many times.
Now to convey to you the difference….”
The guests staying at Styles are, yet
again, quite a versatile bunch. This time round we have Norton, Mr Allerton,
Miss Cole, Doctor Franklin and his wife Barbara, Nurse Craven, Colonel Luttrell
and his wife Daisy, Boyd-Carrington, and to top it off even Hasting’s daughter,
Judith. But what brought us to Styles one more time? Poirot called on Hastings
as he believes that one of the people staying in the house is an experienced,
five-time murderer. What we do not know is which one, and as the murders start,
the question needs to get its answer fast.
As I previously said, Curtain gets pretty nostalgic as
Hastings reminiscences his live, his times with Poirot, and their old cases. Soon
the nostalgia and melancholy grow into a generally sad feeling. Poirot’s last case is among the saddest
Agatha Christie books – especially if you have grown to be quite attached to
her Belgian detective. Quite honestly, Curtain
is simply heart breaking…
I do recommend reading both of those
books but make sure you read Curtain after
you have read quite some number of Poirot’s other cases as it is better to have
some general idea of his character and his previous work. After all, you have to meet Hercule first before you
ever get the chance to say goodbye to him.
